Orwell Award Announcement SusanOhanian.Org Home


Outrages

 

9486 in the collection  

    Allapattah students pen words of hope to laid-off Macy's employees

    Ohanian Comment: What
    a terrific project. This makes me proud to call
    myself teacher. Thank you, Ms. Martin. And
    thank you, Paul Moore, for putting this in the
    horrible NCLB/FCAT context.

    If you'd like to write a note of appreciation
    to this teacher's class, here's her address:
    Cointa Martin
    Cmartin22@dadeschools.net

    WRITE!

    I can't help but add that my research has shown
    that Maya Angelou, for whom this school is
    named, is probably the author most used on high
    stakes standardized tests.


    Paul Moore Comment:

    Something is terribly wrong at Miami's
    Maya
    Angelou Elementary School
    ! According to the
    Florida Department of Education, Maya Angelou
    became a failing school last year. Strange
    since the year before it was a model school, an
    "A" school, judged by the same Florida
    Comprehensive Assessment Test (FCAT). But test
    scores don't lie so Maya Angelou was placed,
    along with neighboring inner-city schools like
    Holmes Elementary and Liberty City Elementary,
    on the state's list of schools subject to
    Differentiated Accountability (DA). DA is a
    fancy way of threatening that Maya Angelou will
    be closed if the kids there don't become better
    test takers.

    One can only imagine the goings on in one of
    these failing schools. That may have inspired
    the Miami Herald to send its education
    reporter Kathleen McGrory into Maya Angelou for
    a look see. And McGrory found Ms. Cointa
    Martin's second grade class ignoring FCAT test
    prep and living in the real world. It's the
    world where Macy's lays off 600 of its Miami
    office employees and the children dare to care.

    McCrory's story is accompanied by pictures of
    Kayla Yorks, a 7-year-old, and Daniel
    Hernandez, 7 too. Daniel wrote about
    unemployment, "It isn't easy when you lose your
    job. You have to buy things for your family,
    but you don't have enough money." Daniel's
    classmate and budding philosopher, 8-year-old
    Charlene Montero, added, "Deserts may seem
    empty at first, but if you know where to look,
    you will find they are full of life." The story
    ultimately introduces us to a cross section of
    Ms. Martin's class and of the community.
    There's Kayla, Daniel, Charlene, and Cierra
    Rodgers, Jackeline Ramirez, Javier Nunez, and
    Michael Hollomon.

    Incredibly, the kids from the failing Maya
    Angelou Elementary seemed to reach accomplished
    adult professionals with their concern. Their
    "little tiny inspirational posters" brought
    tears to the eyes of broadcast manager Margaret
    Torok. Retouching specialist Nelson Viera said,
    "It reminded me that there's so much hope out
    there---we just have to open our eyes and see
    it. Truthfully, it made me feel so much
    better." The Macy's employees responded with
    letters and a book created by Viera. Veteran
    teacher Martin wrapped up the lesson for her
    kids, "When you are kind to someone, they will
    be kind to you."

    Next year, as third graders, Ms. Martin's
    charges will face the FCAT. The test awards no
    points for kindness. Florida is in the middle
    of a groundbreaking experiment with childhood
    accountability and the educational value of
    humiliation If the 9-year-olds do not meet the
    reading standards of the FCAT they will be
    severely punished. The educational policy of
    the state, executed by Governor Charlie Crist
    and the Commissioner of Education Eric Smith,
    is to brand such children as failed. That is
    kept in confidence but then to make sure the
    lesson on accountability is seared into a
    child's brain and self-image forever, they are
    publicly humiliated. During the next school
    year their classmates proceed to grade four
    while they join a new group of kids to repeat
    third grade.

    The FDOE does not report this but the vastly
    disproportionate number of the children
    retained in the third grade come from schools
    like Maya Angelou Elementary. They are children
    living in poverty. They are children of color.
    They are Ms. Martin's children.


    BY Kathleen McGrory, Miami Herald

    The students in Mrs. Martin's second-grade
    class were saddened by the news: More than 600
    employees at Macy's would be losing their jobs.

    So the kids put pencil to paper.

    "My teacher told me you are losing your job,"
    one little girl wrote. "I don't have anything
    to give you. But I will share what I learned
    today."

    In a series of two dozen letters, the children
    from Maya Angelou Elementary in Allapattah went
    on to describe their favorite science facts.

    "Did you know that only two ants can lift a
    dead bug?" wrote Cierra Rodgers, 8. "Also, ants
    communicate with their antennae. Hope you find
    a new job."

    Perhaps unknowingly, 8-year-old Charlene
    Montero offered some insightful words.

    "Deserts may seem empty at first," she wrote.
    "But if you know where to look, you will find
    that they are full of life."

    600 JOBS GONE

    The children learned about the layoffs through
    their teacher, Cointa Martin. Martin's husband
    was among the Macy's employees affected by the
    cuts, which eliminated more than 600 positions
    in the company's Miami office.

    The layoffs, which were announced in February,
    take effect April 30. One of the Miami business
    district's largest employers, Macy's is one of
    dozens of Florida companies having to eliminate
    positions because of the economy. The state's
    unemployment rate has already reached 9.4
    percent, the highest it's been since 1976, and
    is likely to go even higher.

    "Everyday, my husband came home with stories
    about different employees who were losing their
    jobs," Martin said. "Some of them have their
    husbands sick in the hospital."

    Martin, a veteran elementary-school teacher,
    told her students what was happening. It struck
    a chord with the kids.

    Daniel Hernandez, 7, said he felt sad and
    worried for the workers.

    "It isn't easy when you lose your job," he
    said. "You have to buy things for your family,
    but you don't have enough money."

    Daniel and his classmates wanted to send gifts
    to the Macy's employees.

    But their teacher had another idea. "I said to
    them, `We don't have any material things to
    share with them, but we have knowledge. You
    have so many books. You can find something that
    you can share with them in there.'"

    The students got to work right away, scouring
    their science books for interesting nuggets
    they could share with the employees.

    They wrote their notes in pencil on loose-leaf
    paper.

    Some were funny.

    "I learned that snakes can eat big animals such
    as a leopard," wrote Javier Nuñez, 8. "I
    learned that pythons are the largest snakes."

    Others were full of insight.

    Penned Jackeline Ramirez, 8: "How will you find
    your way to where you are going? The North Star
    helped sailors know where their ship was
    located."

    All of the children affixed an inspirational
    picture to the bottom of their letter. And many
    urged the employees to believe in themselves.

    "I started to tear up," said Margaret Torok,
    who is losing her job as a broadcast manager
    for Macy's.

    "They read like little tiny inspirational
    posters. If that doesn't lift your spirits, I
    don't know what will."

    The Macy's executives hung the notes in the
    main hallway, beside the advertising
    department. Many wrote back to the children,
    thanking them for their thoughtfulness.

    Nelson Viera, a retouching specialist, was so
    moved he made the class a book of colorful
    nature photographs he had taken.

    "It reminded me that there's so much hope out
    there -- we just have to open our eyes and see
    it," Viera said. "Truthfully, it made me feel
    so much better."

    WELL RECEIVED

    Recently, Martin gathered her class in the
    school library. "Boys and girls, your letters
    were very well received," she told the
    children. "Some of the people were so grateful,
    they cried."

    Then, Martin held up a dozen envelopes and the
    colorful book.

    "These are letters that the people at Macy's
    wrote to you," she said. "And this is a very
    special book made especially for you."

    The children cheered.

    "I'm glad that they are happy," Michael
    Hollomon, 8, said of his new penpals.

    Martin said the kids had learned an important
    lesson: "When you are kind to someone, they
    will be kind to you."

    — Kathleen McGrory, with commentary by Paul Moore
    Miami Herald
    2009-03-28
    http://www.miamiherald.com/news/5min/story/971891.html


    INDEX OF OUTRAGES

Pages: 380   
[1] 2 3 4 5 6  Next >>    Last >>


FAIR USE NOTICE
This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of education issues vital to a democracy. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information click here. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.