|
|
|
Super Stemmys: Book Review
Review Super Stemmys, a stem cell story Posted by Jef Akst Stem cells to save the day! Or the heart, at least. That's the plot of a new children's book on adult (or repair) stem cells, published by the Repair Stem Cell Institute (RSCI) -- a Dallas- and Bangkok-based public affairs company that provides interested patients with contact information for stem cell treatment centers around the world. "It's a nice idea," said cell biologist Mahendra Rao of Life Technologies, a California-based biotechnology company. "I think it's good to tell kids about all current events, [including] technological breakthroughs," and "it's a nice book for kids [with] illustrations [that] are nice and a logical flow to it." The RSCI aims to connect patients seeking adult stem cell therapies with 10 medical centers (all of which are outside of the US), and the goal of the new book, Super Stemmys: Doris and the Super Cells, is to increase awareness that these treatments even exist in the first place. "I want people to know that these options are out there so they can consider these options in their treatment decisions," said book author David Granovsky, director of communications for RSCI. "The book is the quintessential element of distribution of that information in a digestible format, which is hopefully also fun and educational." Using rhyme and illustrations by Greg Boone (penname Boonie), the book tells the story of a bone marrow stem cell named Doris -- named after University of Minnesota researcher Doris Taylor, one of the first to treat cardiac disease with skeletal muscle and later stem cells -- who is called into action to fix a failing heart. "I just felt it was a little too narrow," Rao added, noting that the book "was completely focused on bone marrow [stem cells] -- a very small subset of the whole stem cell field." Indeed, there is no mention of induced pluripotent stem cells or embryonic stem cells. "If I wanted to write a child's book on stem cells, I would have tried to give them a flavor for the whole wide range of stem cells," Rao said. "All stem cells are not the same." "It's just not a complete story," agreed cell biologist Pamela Robey of the National Institutes of Health. Robey also noted that the book is also a bit unclear with regard to the science behind Doris's mission. "It was very nebulous about how that cell would fix the heart," she said. Super Stemmys "didn't really depict exactly where the field stands. There was kind of this underlying [notion] that any stem cell can do anything, and I don't think we believe that these days." The book depicts Doris and other stem cells being extracted from the bone marrow, put into culture, and then re-injected into a patient where they proceed to directly repair heart tissue. At some point between extraction and re-injection, Doris grows from an undersized "stemmy" to a gigantic "super stemmy" -- a transformation that "does not match what current technology does or presumes to do," Rao said. Such stem cells "don't repair structure [as the book implies] but may improve blood supply by providing signals to endogenous repair processes," he explained. But are these inaccuracies enough to misinform children's understanding of stem cell biology? Granovsky said that the depiction of Doris growing bigger was simply Boone's interpretation of the text -- an interpretation that likely comes from his background as a comic book illustrator, he added. Furthermore, with the science advancing at a rapid pace, Granovsky said he chose to breeze over some of the details of the mechanism to avoid "dating" the book. "I wanted it to be educational, but I didn't want to portray it as the end-all-be-all [of] how stem cells work." "One should not expect to cover everything in the first book [on stem cells]," molecular biologist Xiangru Xu of Yale University wrote in an email to The Scientist. The book is "really a scientific-based fairytale [that] reflects roughly the essential facts and expectations about stem cells [thus] far." Wanting to reach "as large an audience as possible," Granovsky wrote the book at a 6th grade level -- no easy task given "the inherent science and unknown science in it," he said. The problem is that the illustrations and rhyming parts of the book appear to be targeted towards a much younger audience, Robey said -- such as kindergartners or 1st graders. But at that age, they don't "even know what a cell is," she said. "The idea of teaching children about [stem cells] is a good one; I just didn't see this piece as being at a level that would be understandable." Still, Xu said, "I think this is a [great] way to educate the young generation about the contemporary, exciting works in biomedical science research and the great potential for its medical applications." Read more: Super Stemmys, a stem cell story - The Scientist - Magazine of the Life Sciences http://www.the-scientist.com/blog/display/57276/#ixzz0kcQK7zTV I very much understand and appreciate the need to educate the public about the need for stem cell research. But do we need to start with the picture book crowd? — blog |
FAIR USE NOTICE
This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically
authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to
advance understanding of education issues vital to a democracy. We believe this constitutes a
'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US
Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is
distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the
included information for research and educational purposes. For more information click here. If you wish to use copyrighted material from
this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from
the copyright owner.
