Orwell Award Announcement SusanOhanian.Org Home


The Crocodile in the Common Core Standards

Publication Date: 2011-10-25

This appeared on Daily Censored on October 18, 2011, provoking enthusiastic response on Twitter and Facebook. And there are good comments at the Daily Censored site.


"[A]s you grow up in this world you realize people really donât give a shit about what you feel or what you think." Thus, Common Core Standards architect David Coleman delivered[1] the core pedagogy of the Common Core State Standards (CCSS) to educators gathered at the New York State Department of Education in April 2011. Listen to a few more of Colemanâs proclamations and you have to ask yourself if this is a man of deep experience and rectitude or just a cuckoo bird let loose on a hapless bunch of educrats who donât know how to voice dissent. Coleman was on stage one hour 59 minutes in Chancellor's Hall decreeing the new reality of teaching in public schools across America. No one in the audience challenged his bizarre declarations.

Maybe they were in a state of shock.

Or maybe the hall was silent because Coleman is billed as "a leading author and architect of the CCSS, and our professional organizations have already caved in on the Common Core--without a shot being fired. As premier standards entrepreneur, Coleman is a busy man, having already co-written the Common Core State Curriculum Standards and the Publishersâ Criteria for the Common Core State Standards in English Language Arts and Literacy[2]) . Coleman insists that teachers must train students to be workers in the Global Economy. In his words, "It is rare in a working environment that someone says, 'Johnson, I need a market analysis by Friday but before that I need a compelling account of your childhood.'" Translation to the classroom: No more primary grade essays about lost teeth or middle school essays about prepubescent angst. Instead, students must provide critical analysis of the "Allegory of the Cave" from Plato's Republic, listed as an "exemplary informational text" in the Common Core State Standards for Language Arts.[3] If that's judged as over the top for 12-year-olds, thereâs always Ronald Reagan's 1988 "Address to Students at Moscow State University."

As though literacy is to prepare children only for a working environment. And as though personal opinion isn't vital in a working environment.

Coleman is on a mission to slash both the amount of personal narrative in writing and the amount of fiction in reading. This is based not on any experience teaching --except at the University of London--but because, he insists, readers gain "world knowledge" through nonfiction, which he calls "informational text." Listening to Coleman evokes Kafka's The Castle: "You have been in the village a few days and already think you know everything better than everyone here." The difference is that Coleman provides no evidence that he's been in the public school village even a few days.

Skeptics who might doubt that replacing Brown Bear, Brown Bear with a Wikipedia entry on Ursus arctos will stave off our nationâs economic woes might wonder: Why, if fiction is no more vital than leftover turnips, is there a Nobel Prize in Literature and not in lawyer'â briefs or material from the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco's Web site (listed as a Common Core exemplary text). For more on the prescribed informational text, the reader is advised to do what not more than fourscore in the country have done: Read Appendixes A and B of the Common Core State Curriculum Standards. Surely Appendix A will frost your toes (http://www.corestandards.org/assets/Appendix_A.pdf) and then Appendix B will freeze your heart. David Coleman and his Common Core Standards cohorts decree that once teens get through Ovid's Metamorphoses, they can move on to an article from Scientific American about the Higgs boson. (English/Language Arts Literacy Examples ELA-1 and ELAâ"2: Focused Literacy, Extended Constructed Response Type, p. 684 (http://www.corestandards.org/assets/Appendix_B.pdf)

Text That Informs

Hereâs how Michael Dirda opens his new book[4] On Conan Doyle: Or, The Whole Art of Storytelling


Graham Greene famously observed that only in childhood do books have any deep influence on our lives.

How many adults first learned about moral complexity from the final chapter of Beverly Cleary's Henry Huggins,when the dog Ribsy must choose between two equally kind masters?

Who, at any age, can read unmoved the last pages of Tarzan of the Apes when the rightful Lord Greystoke,deliberating sacrificing his own hope for happiness, quietly says, "My mother was an ape. . . I never knew who my father was."

In her New York Times Magazine blog,[5] Ilene Silverman writes of her three favorite books as a teenager: The Chocolate War, Separate Peace, and My Darling My Hamburger. For the teen Silverman, these novels were filled with informational text, providing important information about the world.

Interviewed for the film Hey, Boo: Harper Lee and to Kill a Mockingbird, in which a range of people--from Roseanne Cash to Tom Brokow-- talk about the important world knowledge gained from reading Harper Lee's novel. Ph.D. Pulitzer Prize winner Richard Russo says, "Masterpieces tap into something essential to us--at the heart of who we are and how we love." James Patterson says, "Youâre suspecting something about Booâ"which should tell you something about yourself."

Of course David Coleman insists w'âre supposed to convince students that nobody gives a shit about how they feel or their need to find out something about themselves.

Writing in The New Yorker, Louis Menand says[vi], "When I read a poem I relate it to all the other poems I have read. . . past poems condition my response to any new poem. And the really new poem conditions my response to all the poems that precede it. After 'Prufrock,' the Inferno is, ever so slightly, a different poem. Thus text informs text backwards and forwards. Sarah Bakewell says the same thing in How To Live: A Life of Montaigne,[7] insisting that readers approach Montaigne "from their private perspectives, contributing their own experience of life. . . a two-person encounter between writer and reader."

In his introduction to Poetâs Choice[8], MacArthur Fellowship winner and award-winning poet Edward Hirsch advises that biographical, literary, and historical info provides readers a context for their reading. The teacher decides which kind of information is most relevant for each work. The reader decides too. But in presenting his notion of a model lesson for teaching Martin Luther King Jr's "Letter to a Birmingham Jail," David Coleman snidely rejects out of hand such approaches as providing any biographical, cultural, or historical context for the letter--just as he rejects reader response theory which focuses on the reader as an active agent in the wor'âs meaning. Instead, Coleman champions what amounts to New Criticism on steroids, insisting that the reader's sole focus must be only on the words in the text

Although a multitude of expert readers show that the emperor of the Common Core Standards is naked, as long as such professional organizations as the National Council of Teachers of English (NCTE) and the International Reading Association (IRA) remain silent, David Coleman seems safe in shouting his absurd declarations from the rooftops. Instead of offering any informed resistance, NCTE and IRA are occupied with figuring out how they can make money from embracing the Common Core--and staving off dissidents in their own ranks. Last year, NCTE resorted to technical excuses for squashing a proposed resolution against the Common Core. But the resolution proposers are back: See Resolution Sent to NCTE.

Money Talks, Money Legislates, Money Delivers Classroom Lessons

The Common Core State Standards exist because the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation wanted them. To help their aide-de-camps, the president and the U. S. Secretary of Education, pretend that these are state and not national standards, the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation sent buckets of money to the National Governors Association and Council of Chief State School Officers to act as sponsors. More tons of money to the National PTA to spread the good word and so on. As I revealed in an article in Extra![9] very few media have pointed to the money source. Of course very few media even bother to mention anything about the Common Core.

I'd like to introduce David Coleman, Bill Gates, Arne Duncan--and all the rest of the Standardistos-- to Chris, who found handwriting very difficult but insisted on laboriously copying out Beatrix Potter's Tale of Squirrel Nutkin in his notebook. Every word. Dougie asked him, "Why are you doing this? Miz O gave us all our own copy of the book." And Chris answered, "I know. I just like the way the words feel." This from a boy who entered third grade loudly complaining about how much he hated both reading and writing. This is the boy who ended the year exchanging letters with his favorite poet, Jack Prelutsky. 'âd like to introduce this motley school deform crew to Chris' classmate Leslie, who contacted me 25 years later, to talk about the importance of Amelia Bedelia in her life.

This Common Core den of thieves who are stealing the literary rights of our students should read Arnold Lobe'âs lovely little fable, "The Crocodile in the Bedroom'â[10] A crocodile who loved the neat and tidy rows of the flowers on the wallpaper in his bedroom was coaxed outside into the garden by his wife, who invited him to smell the roses and the lilies of the valley. The crocodile couldn't stand the "terrible tangle" of freely growing flowers, and went to bed, preferring to stare at neat and tidy wallpaper. There, "he turned a very pale and sickly shade of green."

With David Coleman as their spokesman out on the stump, the National Governors Association, the Council of Chief State School Officers, and the U. S. Department of Education, acting in concert with the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, prescribe a very pale, sickly shade of green future for our vibrant and deliciously messy classrooms. Certainly, Lobel's moral, Without a doubt, there is such a thing as too much order, applies even more to the classroom than it does to wallpaper. And letting our corporate school reformers steamroll our schools into a neat and tidy standardized product puts our children in great peril.



[1] David Coleman, "Bringing the Common Core to Life", New York State Department of Education, April 28, 2011
http://usny.nysed.gov/rttt/resources/bringing-the-common-core-to-life.html

[2] David Coleman and Susan Pimentel, "Publishers' Criteria for the Common Core State Standards in English Language Arts and Literacy, Grades Kâ"2â http://www.edweek.org/media/k-2-criteria-blog.pdf

[3] National Governors Association and Council of Chief State School Officers, âCommon Core State Standards,â http://corestandards.org/assets/CCSSI_ELA%20Standards.pdf

[4] Michael Dirda, On Conan Doyle: Or, The Whole Art of Storytelling, Princeton University Press, 2011

[5] Ilene Silverman, âThe 6th Floor, New York Times Magazine blog, Sept. 21, 2011

[6] Louis Menand, "A Critic at Large," The New Yorker, Sept. 19, 2011, 81

[7] Sarah Bakewell, How to Live: A Life of Montaigne, Other Press 2010, 9

[8] Edward Hirsch, Poet's Choice, Harcourt Inc. 2006

[9] Susan Ohanian, "'Race to the Top' and the Bill Gates Connection," Extra! September 2010 http://www.fair.org/index.php?page=4147

[10] Arnold Lobel,"âCrocodile in the Bedroom," Fables, HarperCollins 1980


FAIR USE NOTICE
This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of education issues vital to a democracy. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information click here. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.